On January 2, 2026, a penthouse at Vita at Grove Isle closed for $16.1 million, according to the deal record on Traded. It was a new 5,225-square-foot residence bought directly from the developer, CMC Group, and the price worked out to $3,081 per square foot.
Six months later, on July 7, a residence at 2655 South Bayshore Drive closed for $16.15 million. That is Mr. C Residences, and the South Florida Business Journal reported the deal as a record sale at a Coconut Grove condo. According to Traded, the buyer got 6,611 square feet at $2,442 per square foot.
The two buyers spent almost exactly the same amount. The Mr. C buyer got about 1,386 more square feet. In Coconut Grove this year, buying new did not raise the total price. It raised the price of every square foot, and the buyer of the new home took less space for the same money.
The price of newness, per foot
The gap between the two closings is $639 per square foot. The Grove Isle penthouse sold at about 26% more per foot than the Bayshore residence. If you applied Mr. C's July rate to the Vita penthouse's 5,225 square feet, it would come to about $12.8 million. The other $3.3 million or so paid for things the floor plan doesn't show. Coconut Grove Magazine describes Vita as a newly delivered building with Italian marble and smart-home systems that Ugo Colombo oversaw personally, on a 20-acre private island off the Grove.
These are two homes in two different settings, so the comparison is not exact. Grove Isle is a private island address, and Mr. C sits on South Bayshore Drive. Each closing is a single data point and not a building average. Still, the pattern holds across the other 2026 resale records along the bay.
| Building | Closed | Price | Size | Price per sq. ft. |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Vita at Grove Isle penthouse, new | Jan. 2, 2026 | $16,100,000 | 5,225 | $3,081 |
| Mr. C Residences, resale | Jul. 7, 2026 | $16,150,000 | 6,611 | $2,442 |
| Two Park Grove #15C, resale | Apr. 30, 2026 | $4,500,000 | 1,954 | $2,303 |
| Grove at Grand Bay #1602S, resale | Mar. 13, 2026 | $7,000,000 | 3,607 | $1,940 |
According to Traded's record, the Two Park Grove unit closed for $4.5 million on April 30, which works out to $2,303 per square foot. At Grove at Grand Bay, the Bjarke Ingels-designed pair of towers that Terra built, a 3,607-square-foot unit closed on March 13 at $1,940 per square foot. A buyer paying the Vita penthouse's rate could have bought nearly 59% more space at the Grand Bay rate.
Mr. C's own pricing gives a sense of where an established Grove tower settles. The Real Deal reported a sale there in January 2025, units 1702-1706, at $8,620,875, or $2,371 per square foot. The July 2026 record closed at $2,442 per square foot, which is close to that earlier figure. The higher total price came from a much larger residence, not a sharply higher rate per foot.
Why the neighborhood average understates condos
Anyone comparing Miami neighborhoods has probably seen one per-square-foot figure for Coconut Grove. Haute Residence's Q3 2026 luxury report covers July 1 through September 30, 2026, in ZIP code 33133 with Coral Gables records excluded, at $2 million and above. It counted 57 recorded sales totaling $233.9 million, at a weighted $1,435 per square foot.
That figure mixes property types. Single-family homes made up 41 of those 57 sales and about 75% of the dollar volume. Condominiums made up 16 sales and $59,572,500. The report itself says the combined number does not replace building-level and unit-level comparisons for a condo buyer. Every 2026 Grove condo closing in the table above cleared $1,435 per square foot by at least $505. A buyer who plans a Grove condo budget around the neighborhood-wide figure will be short at every one of those buildings.
The same report's October 14, 2026 snapshot listed 33 properties asking $2 million or more. Seventeen of them were condominiums, and the group's weighted asking price was $1,561 per square foot. The report calls Q3 2026 a first-edition baseline. It does not measure appreciation or a slowdown, and the gap between asking and recorded prices should not be read as a discount.
The newest homes start below the luxury threshold
The $2 million cutoff in that report leaves out an entire tier of new Grove construction.
Arbor Residences is a 45-home boutique condominium designed by Behar & Font, around the corner from the central corridor and CocoWalk. PROFILEmiami reported that Arbor received its Certificate of Occupancy on August 20, 2026, when it had passed 80% sold. At that point the remaining two-bedroom-plus-den and three-bedroom residences were priced from $1.8 million. Amenities include a rooftop terrace, a pool deck, a fitness center, 24-hour concierge service and valet.
THE WELL Coconut Grove sits even lower in the price range, and buyers wait longer for it. According to PROFILEmiami, Terra and AB Asset Management broke ground in early 2026 with a $410 million construction loan from TYKO Capital, the largest construction loan ever closed in Coconut Grove. The plans call for 194 residences across eight stories, designed by Arquitectonica with interiors by Meyer Davis. Units range from one to four bedrooms and 960 to 4,200 square feet, with prices starting at $1.5 million. More than half of the residences were pre-sold at groundbreaking, and the opening target is the fourth quarter of 2028.
The top of the new-construction range is still at Grove Isle. When Coconut Grove Magazine reported Vita's completion on February 2, 2026, most of its 65 residences had sold. The remaining inventory was priced from $6.5 million, and a two-story penthouse with a private pool and rooftop terrace was listed at $22 million.
Pick the tier, then pick the timeline
New construction in the Grove now runs from a $1.5 million pre-construction entry point to a $22 million penthouse, and the timing splits into two groups: delivered now, or targeted for late 2028.
Two of the new buildings already have keys to hand over. Arbor is the entry point, and Vita is the top, where the 2026 penthouse closing shows what the newest finishes cost per foot. THE WELL has the lowest starting price of the three, but its opening is targeted for late 2028, so its buyers accept a construction timeline in exchange for the lower entry price.
If space matters more than newness, the established towers on South Bayshore Drive are the place to look: Park Grove, Grove at Grand Bay and Mr. C. The 2026 records show them trading at a lower price per square foot than the newest construction, so the same budget buys a larger home. The $16 million July closing at Mr. C showed that this year.
Coconut Grove Magazine reported that many of Vita's buyers were local Miami residents moving from large estate homes in nearby neighborhoods, who wanted to downsize without giving up space. For those buyers, the 2026 records turn the choice into a math problem. At the Grove Isle penthouse's rate, $16 million bought 5,225 square feet. At the Bayshore rate, the same money bought 6,611 square feet. Anyone giving up a large house should know how much each of those square feet costs before choosing a building.
For more on the Grove beyond its towers, our guides cover bayfront versus village living and buying a historic Coconut Grove home. Our Coconut Grove neighborhood page covers the area as a whole.
FAQ
What does the newest construction in Coconut Grove sell for per square foot? The Vita at Grove Isle penthouse that closed on January 2, 2026 sold at $3,081 per square foot. That is the highest per-foot figure among the 2026 Grove condo closings covered here.
Is there a new Coconut Grove condo under $2 million? Yes. Arbor Residences priced its remaining homes from $1.8 million when it received its Certificate of Occupancy in August 2026. THE WELL Coconut Grove starts at $1.5 million, with opening targeted for the fourth quarter of 2028.
Why is the neighborhood's average price per square foot lower than the condo sales? The $1,435 Q3 2026 figure covers houses and condos together, and single-family homes made up 41 of the 57 sales at $2 million and above that quarter.
If you're deciding between a newly delivered Grove residence and more space in an established Bayshore tower, The Paiz Group would be glad to walk through the price-per-foot math with you, building by building. If you already own in the Grove and want to see how your residence compares with this year's closings, start with Get Your Home Value.